Pricing and fees
Fixed Fee or Hourly: Which Suits Which Engineering Project
Fixed fee or hourly is a choice about who carries the risk of extra hours: the firm, under a fixed fee, or the client, under hourly. The right choice depends on how well the firm can predict the hours.
On this page
Terms Used
- Fixed fee (lump sum): one price for a defined scope, whatever the hours turn out to be.
- Hourly (time and materials): the hours worked at agreed rates, plus expenses.
- Not-to-exceed: an hourly fee with a ceiling the firm can’t bill past without the client’s agreement. Also called an upset limit.
- Additional services: work outside the agreed scope, priced separately.
The Question Behind the Choice
Both methods can be profitable. The choice comes down to one question: how well can you predict the hours? If you have done this kind of project many times, with this kind of client, a fixed fee lets you earn from your experience. If the work depends on what you find, on approvals or on decisions you do not control, hourly keeps the risk where it belongs.
Side by Side
| Question | Fixed fee | Hourly |
|---|---|---|
| The client knows the cost | At the start | As the work goes, or up to a cap |
| If the work takes fewer hours | The firm keeps the difference | The client pays less |
| If the work takes more hours | The firm absorbs it, unless the scope changed | The client pays more |
| Administration | Less detail on invoices | Timesheet detail behind every invoice |
| Depends most on | A good estimate and a written scope | Rates that cover overhead and profit |
What Each Method Does When the Hours Are Wrong
The difference between the two methods only shows when the hours differ from the estimate. For example, take one project, estimated at 400 hours at an average rate of $150, so $60,000 either way.
| Example, round numbers | Takes 340 hours | Takes 400 hours | Takes 480 hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| Value of the hours at $150 | $51,000 | $60,000 | $72,000 |
| Fixed fee of $60,000: the firm bills | $60,000 | $60,000 | $60,000 |
| Hourly: the firm bills | $51,000 | $60,000 | $72,000 |
| Hourly with a $60,000 not-to-exceed | $51,000 | $60,000 | $60,000 |
In this example, the fixed fee earns $9,000 more than hourly when the team is faster, and gives away $12,000 when it is slower. Hourly passes both to the client. The last row is the one to notice: a not-to-exceed gives the firm the loss of a fixed fee when the hours run over, and none of the gain when they come in under.
When a Fixed Fee Suits
- The firm has delivered similar projects and has their hours by phase.
- The scope, deliverables and number of reviews can be written down.
- The client decides quickly and the approvals path is known.
- The project is short enough that rates will not change much before it ends.
A fixed fee is also how a firm earns from getting better. Standard details, templates and tools that save hours raise the margin on fixed-fee work and lower the bill on hourly work. A firm that invests in speed and bills only hourly gives the saving away.
When Hourly Suits
- Investigations, assessments and studies whose scope depends on findings.
- Work on existing buildings or sites where conditions are unknown.
- Expert advice, litigation support, or open-ended client support.
- Clients who change direction often, or approvals with an uncertain path.
The Middle Paths
A middle path is common, and each one moves the risk in its own way:
- Hourly with a not-to-exceed. The client gets a ceiling. Price the ceiling with a contingency, because the firm carries the overrun and gets none of the saving.
- A fixed fee by phase. A fixed fee for the phases that are clear, and hourly, or a price set later, for the ones that depend on what the early phases find.
- A fixed fee with stated limits. A fixed fee that includes a set number of options, review rounds, meetings and site visits, with anything beyond them priced at hourly rates written into the proposal.
- Hourly with a target. An estimate the firm reports against every month, without a hard cap, for clients who need a budget but accept that the scope is open.
Protecting a Fixed Fee
- Write the scope as deliverables. What will be issued, how many review rounds, how many meetings and site visits.
- State the assumptions. The information the client will provide, the approvals path, what happens if conditions differ.
- List exclusions. What is not in the fee, as clearly as what is.
- Agree how extra work is priced. Hourly rates for additional services, written into the proposal.
- Track hours against the fee every week. See tracking a fixed-fee project.
Protecting an Hourly Fee
An hourly fee carries less risk, not none. Rates below the firm’s costs lose money on every hour, so set them from the firm’s own costs. Invoices well above the estimate the client was given get disputed, so report hours against the estimate every month and warn the client before a ceiling, not after. And hours the client won’t accept as reasonable get written off, which shows up in realization.
Learning Which One Pays
Once a year, list every closed project with its fee method, its fee and the salary cost of its hours. Work out each one’s effective multiplier. Look for the pattern: which kinds of fixed-fee work earn well, and which clients or project types lose money whatever the method. That list is the best guide to the next year’s quotes, and it may show that the kind of work and the client matter more than the method.
Common Mistakes
- Choosing by habit. One method for every project ignores how predictable each one is.
- A fixed fee with no written limits. Without stated review rounds, meetings and visits, the firm has little to point to when a request goes beyond what the fee allowed.
- A not-to-exceed priced like a fixed fee. It carries the overrun risk without the upside, so it needs a contingency.
- Never comparing the results. Without the yearly list, the firm repeats the work that loses money.
A Checklist for Choosing
- Ask how well you can predict the hours, from your own history for this kind of work.
- Ask who controls the things that could change them: you, the client, or neither.
- Put the risk with the party that controls it.
- For a fixed fee, write the deliverables, limits, assumptions and exclusions.
- For hourly, set rates from your costs and report against the estimate monthly.
- For a not-to-exceed, add a contingency to the ceiling.
- Compare every closed project’s effective multiplier by method once a year.
How We Approach This
Whether this work should be fixed fee or hourly is one of the questions our diagnostic answers, project type by project type, from your own records. Every suggestion comes with the figures behind it.
Questions
Is a Fixed Fee or Hourly Better for an Engineering Firm?
Neither on its own. A fixed fee suits work the firm can predict and lets it earn from its experience; hourly suits work whose hours depend on findings, approvals or client decisions.
What Is a Not-To-Exceed Fee?
An hourly fee with a ceiling the firm can’t bill past without the client’s agreement. The client pays less if the work takes fewer hours, and the firm absorbs the hours past the ceiling.
How Do You Protect a Fixed Fee?
Write the scope as deliverables with limits on reviews, meetings and visits, state the assumptions and exclusions, agree rates for extra work, and track hours against the fee every week.
Can You Mix Fixed Fee and Hourly on One Project?
Yes. A fixed fee for the phases that are clear and hourly for the ones that depend on early findings splits the risk between the firm and the client.
Why Do Firms Prefer Fixed Fees for Repeat Work?
Because the firm keeps the hours it saves. Templates, standard details and experience lower the hours, and under a fixed fee the saving is the firm’s; under hourly it goes to the client.
Updates
- : Rewritten at full length: what each method does when the hours are wrong, with a worked example, the middle paths, protecting an hourly fee, common mistakes and a checklist.