Pricing and fees
How to Price Engineering Work: The Four Usual Ways
Pricing engineering work means choosing a fee method (hourly, fixed fee, a percentage of construction cost or value) and checking the fee against the hours, the firm’s overhead and a profit. The method decides who carries the risk if the hours are wrong.
On this page
Terms Used
- Fee method: the way the price is set: hourly, fixed fee, a percentage of construction cost, or value.
- Break-even fee: the fee that covers the hours and the firm’s overhead, with nothing left as profit.
- Target fee: the break-even fee plus the profit the firm plans to earn.
- Not-to-exceed: a ceiling on an hourly fee, past which the firm can’t bill without the client’s agreement.
- Contingency: hours added to an estimate for the unknowns in it.
The Four Usual Ways
| Method | How the fee is set | Who carries the risk of extra hours | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hourly (time and materials) | Hours worked × agreed rates, plus expenses | The client | Scope that depends on findings, studies, expert advice |
| Fixed fee (lump sum) | One price for a defined scope | The firm | Repeat work with a clear scope |
| Percentage of construction cost | A share of the construction budget | Shared, loosely | Clients and sectors used to it; early budgeting |
| Value pricing | The value of the result to the client | The firm | Work where the firm’s know-how changes the outcome |
Whatever the method, the same sum sits underneath it: the hours the work will take, what those hours cost the firm, and the profit the firm wants. The method decides who carries the risk if the hours are wrong.
Hourly
Hourly pricing means the client pays for the hours used, at rates agreed in advance, usually by role. It is the safest method for the firm when the work cannot be fully defined: an investigation, a condition assessment, expert advice, or design that depends on approvals. Clients often ask for a ceiling, a not-to-exceed amount, which turns it into a capped hourly fee.
The weakness is that a firm that gets faster earns less. Hourly work pays for hours, so the know-how that saves them earns nothing extra. The rates themselves have to be right, too: we work them out from the firm’s costs in setting hourly rates.
Fixed Fee
A fixed fee is one price for a defined scope. Clients like the certainty, and a firm that knows the work well keeps the gain when it finishes in fewer hours. It also keeps the loss when it does not. A fixed fee is only as safe as three things: the estimate of hours behind it, the written scope and assumptions, and the firm’s habit of raising changes. We compare the two in fixed fee or hourly.
Percentage of Construction Cost
A percentage fee is a share of the construction budget. It is quick to agree and familiar in some sectors. Its drawback is that the fee follows the construction cost, which may not match the work: a complex renovation with a small budget can take more design hours than a simple building with a large one.
For example, 8% of a $2,000,000 construction budget is $160,000. If the hours estimate says the work needs $190,000 of fee to cover its costs and profit, the percentage is $30,000 short before the first drawing. If you quote this way, check the percentage against the hours the work will really take, and say in the proposal what happens to the fee if the construction budget changes.
Value Pricing
Value pricing sets the fee from what the result is worth to the client: a faster approval, a lower construction cost, an avoided shutdown. It can earn far more per hour than any other method, and it needs a client who sees the value and a firm that can explain it. It suits a part of a project, such as a study or a value engineering exercise, better than a whole design contract. The cost sum still applies: value pricing is a reason to charge above the target fee, not below it.
Start from Your Costs, Whatever the Method
The same sum sits under every method. The hours by phase and role, valued at each role’s salary cost and multiplied up for the firm’s overhead, give the break-even fee: below it, the project loses money. Divided for the profit the firm plans, they give the target fee. The market then decides how far above the target you can go, or how much of the profit a competitive bid gives up.
Target fee = salary cost of the hours × (1 + overhead rate) ÷ (1 − profit margin)
| Example, round numbers | Amount |
|---|---|
| Hours estimated, by phase and role | 600 |
| Salary cost of those hours, at an average of $50 | $30,000 |
| Break-even fee at a 150% overhead rate ($30,000 × 2.5) | $75,000 |
| Target fee for a 15% profit ($75,000 ÷ 0.85) | $88,235 |
In this example, a fee between $75,000 and about $88,000 covers the costs but earns less than the planned profit; below $75,000 the project loses money, whatever the method. Both figures assume the hours estimate holds and every hour is paid for. If similar projects have run over or had hours written off, allow for it, through the contingency below or the realization the firm achieves: at 90% realization, the target becomes $88,235 ÷ 0.90 ≈ $98,039. The overhead rate article shows how to work out the second line for your own firm.
Price from Your History
The best estimate of a project’s hours is how many hours the last similar projects took. A firm that records hours by phase on every project, and compares them with the fee when each project closes, prices each year a little more accurately than the last.
Turn that history into a short estimating sheet: for each kind of work, the hours per unit that drives it. For example, hours per drawing sheet, per kilometre of road, per building storey or per site visit. A new estimate then starts from the firm’s own record rather than from memory, and the project manager’s judgement goes into what is different about this project.
Price the Unknowns
Every estimate has parts the firm can predict and parts it can’t. Price them differently:
- Add a contingency for the unknowns you can name, such as existing conditions or an approvals path, and say what it covers.
- Split the fee by phase: a fixed fee for the phases that are clear, and hourly or a later price for the ones that depend on what the early phases find.
- State the assumptions the price rests on, so a change in them is a change in scope. Our article on the fee proposal lists the sentences that do it.
Public Work
On public projects, price is often scored as one part of the evaluation, or negotiated only after the most qualified firm is chosen. In the United States, the Brooks Act has federal agencies negotiate architectural and engineering contracts “on the basis of demonstrated competence and qualification for the type of professional services required and at fair and reasonable prices” (40 U.S.C. 1101). In Ontario each buyer sets its own method; the Ministry of Transportation’s engineering services procurement guide of June 2023 weighted a request for proposal at 10% for price (MTO, June 2023).
How much weight price carries changes what a proposal should emphasize, but not the sum underneath: a fee negotiated after selection still has to cover the hours and the overhead, and should earn a profit. We explain the selection methods in qualifications-based selection.
Which Method for Which Project
- Repeat work, clear scope, known client: fixed fee, priced from your history.
- Investigations, assessments, expert advice: hourly, with a not-to-exceed if the client needs a ceiling.
- Design that depends on early findings: a fixed fee for the first phase, the rest priced once it is known.
- A client or sector that expects a percentage: quote it, but check it against the hours and write in what happens if the budget changes.
- A study whose result saves the client far more than it costs: consider value pricing, above the target fee.
Common Pricing Mistakes
- Starting from a competitor’s fee. Their costs and their hours are not yours.
- Estimating the whole project in one figure. Phases and roles show where the hours are, and where the risk is.
- Leaving the assumptions out. An unwritten assumption can’t become a change order.
- Pricing from the estimate that was missed. Price from what the last project took, not from what it was meant to take.
- Cutting the fee to win and keeping the scope. Cut the scope with it, in writing.
A Checklist for Pricing a Project
- Estimate the hours by phase and role, from your history for this kind of work.
- Value them at each role’s salary cost.
- Multiply by one plus the overhead rate, and divide by one minus the profit margin: that is the target fee. Without the profit, it is break-even.
- Add a contingency for the unknowns you can name.
- Choose the method that puts the risk of extra hours with the party that controls it.
- Write the scope, assumptions, exclusions and rates for extra work into the proposal.
- Compare the fee with the break-even and target fees before it goes out.
- Record the hours by phase as the project runs, and compare them with the estimate at closeout.
How We Approach This
Our growth work reviews fee levels, fixed fee or hourly, and where the firm undercharges, project type by project type, from your own timesheets and invoices. Every recommendation comes with the numbers behind it.
Questions
How Do Engineering Firms Set Their Fees?
By one of four methods: hourly, a fixed fee, a percentage of the construction cost, or the value of the result to the client. Whatever the method, the fee is checked against the hours the work will take, the firm’s overhead and a profit.
What Is the Lowest Fee a Firm Should Accept?
Below the break-even fee, the salary cost of the estimated hours multiplied by one plus the overhead rate, the project loses money. The target fee divides that by one minus the profit margin. For example, $30,000 of salary cost at a 150% overhead rate breaks even at $75,000 (30,000 × 2.5), and earns a 15% profit at $88,235 (75,000 ÷ 0.85). Both assume the hours estimate holds.
Is a Percentage of Construction Cost a Good Way to Price?
It is quick and familiar, but the fee follows the budget rather than the work. Check it against an hours estimate, and say in the proposal what happens to the fee if the budget changes.
How Do You Estimate Hours for a Fee?
From the hours similar projects took, by phase and role. An estimating sheet of hours per unit, such as per drawing sheet or per site visit, turns that history into a starting point.
How Is Price Weighed on Public Projects?
It depends on the buyer. US federal agencies negotiate with the most qualified firm under the Brooks Act; Ontario buyers each set their own method, and the Ministry of Transportation’s June 2023 guide weighted price at 10% in a request for proposal.
Sources
Updates
- : Rewritten at full length: break-even and target fees with a worked example, a percentage fee checked against hours, an estimating sheet from your history, pricing the unknowns, public work and which method suits which project; the Brooks Act and MTO guide re-read.