Utilization and profit
Utilization, Realization and Chargeability: What Each One Tells You
Utilization, chargeability and realization are three rates for an engineering firm’s time and fees. Utilization and chargeability measure how the paid hours were spent; realization measures how much of the work’s value became fees. A firm needs both kinds to see where its profit goes.
On this page
Terms Used
- Standard rate: the hourly rate the firm sets for each person or grade, before any discount.
- Value of the hours: hours charged to a project multiplied by each person’s standard rate.
- Write-off: work the firm decides not to bill, or bills for less than its value.
- Write-up: billing more than the hours’ value, which happens when a fixed-fee project finishes in fewer hours than its fee allowed.
Three Rates, Three Questions
| Rate | Question it answers | Formula |
|---|---|---|
| Utilization | How much of the time we pay for goes to billable work? | Billable hours ÷ total paid hours |
| Chargeability | How much time is charged to projects at all? | Hours charged to projects ÷ total paid hours |
| Realization | How much of that work’s value turns into fees? | Fees billed ÷ value of the hours at standard rates |
The first two rates measure time and the third measures money. That is the whole difference, and it is why a firm needs at least one of each.
Utilization
Utilization measures time. For example, an engineer paid for 40 hours who bills 32 is at 80%. It is the best single measure of how busy the firm is on client work. For a team or the firm, add everyone’s billable hours and divide by everyone’s paid hours; never average the percentages. We cover it in detail in how to calculate utilization, and how to raise it in how to improve utilization.
Chargeability
Chargeability is the share of paid hours charged to any project number, whether or not the client will be billed for them. The two words are often used for the same thing. Where they differ, chargeability counts every hour charged to a project number, including hours the firm has already decided not to bill: warranty work, a goodwill revision, a project the firm is running at its own cost.
The gap between the two rates is time spent on projects that will never be invoiced. For example, if chargeability is 78% and utilization is 71%, seven points of every paid hour went to project work nobody will pay for. Tracking chargeability separately is worth it when that gap is large enough to discuss; if it is small, one rate is enough.
Realization
Realization measures value. Each hour charged to a project has a value at the firm’s standard rate. Realization compares what was actually billed, or collected, with that value.
Realization = fees billed ÷ value of the hours at standard rates
For example, say a project used 400 hours whose standard value is $60,000, and the fee is $48,000. Realization is 80%: a fifth of the work’s value was given away. On an hourly project it falls when hours are written off or rates discounted. On a fixed-fee project it falls when the hours exceed what the fee allowed, and rises above 100% when the team finishes faster.
On Billing and on Collection
Some firms measure realization twice: once on billing (fees invoiced) and once on collection (fees received). The second catches invoices that are disputed or never paid. A project can show strong billing realization and weak collection realization, which points to a client or contract problem rather than an estimating one. Our article on unbilled work in progress covers the time between doing the work and invoicing it.
Where Realization Leaks
Realization rarely drops in one large write-off. It leaks in small amounts, at a few predictable points:
- At invoicing: a project manager trims hours before the invoice goes out, because the total looks high.
- Through discounts: rates reduced to win the work, and never restored.
- Through scope growth: extra work done without a change order, which our article on scope creep and additional services covers.
- At the estimate: a fixed fee set too low for the work it covers.
- Through rework: corrections the firm can’t bill because the error was its own.
- Through expenses: printing, travel or subconsultant mark-ups that the contract allowed but nobody billed.
- At collection: invoices disputed, reduced or never paid.
Each leak has a different owner, which is why realization is most useful read by project and by project manager, not only for the firm.
Why a Busy Firm Can Lose Money
Put utilization and realization together and the picture changes:
| Example, round numbers | Firm A | Firm B |
|---|---|---|
| Paid hours | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| Utilization | 80% | 70% |
| Billable hours | 8,000 | 7,000 |
| Value at $150 an hour | $1,200,000 | $1,050,000 |
| Realization | 75% | 95% |
| Fees | $900,000 | $997,500 |
In this example, Firm A looks busier and earns less from the same payroll. Its people are working; the work is running over fixed fees or being written off. Firm B bills less time and keeps more of its value. High utilization with low realization points to fees set too low for the scope, or scope that grew without a fee.
How Realization Changes the Multiplier
The net multiplier is net revenue divided by the salary cost of the hours charged to projects. Realization sits inside it. A firm can set its standard rates at three times salary cost and still achieve a lower multiplier, because only part of the value is billed.
For example, if standard rates are set at 3.0 times salary cost and realization is 85%, the multiplier achieved is 3.0 × 0.85, or 2.55. At 95% realization the same rates give 2.85. In this example, raising realization from 85% to 95% lifts the multiplier as much as raising every rate by about 12 per cent, without a conversation with any client about rates.
Which Rate to Act On
- Low utilization, high realization: the work is priced well; the firm needs more of it, or less time lost between projects.
- High utilization, low realization: the firm has enough work and is not being paid for all of it. Look at fixed fees, scope changes and write-offs, project by project.
- Both low: start with realization. Adding hours to work that loses value adds losses.
- Both high: check overtime. A team at full stretch keeps these numbers for a quarter, not a year.
Read Them by Project, Client and Kind of Work
The firm-wide rates say whether there is a problem. The same rates by project, client and kind of work say where it is. Three cuts are worth making each quarter:
- By kind of work: realization on, say, municipal design compared with private development shows which work the firm’s fees fit.
- By client: a client whose projects keep landing below the firm’s realization is a pricing conversation, or a client to bid more carefully.
- By project manager: a gap here is worth a conversation, because estimating and handling scope changes can both be taught.
None of this needs new software if timesheets carry a project number and the invoices are in the accounting system. It needs the two to be joined, once a month. Our article on project budget tracking shows the weekly view that catches problems before the invoice.
Measure Them the Same Way Every Time
Each rate is only useful against itself over time. Decide the definitions once, write them down, and keep them, so a change in the number is a change in the firm and not in the sum. Four decisions cover most of it:
- Which hours count as paid hours, and whether holidays and vacation are in them.
- Which projects are billable, and how warranty and goodwill work is coded.
- Which standard rates value the hours, and when they change.
- Whether realization is measured on billing, on collection, or both.
A Checklist for the Three Rates
- Write the four definitions above on one page.
- Give every project a code that says billable or not.
- Set standard rates for each person or grade, and record when they change.
- Each week, report utilization by person and hours against fee by project.
- Each month, report realization by project, on billing and on collection.
- Each quarter, compare realization by kind of work, client and project manager.
- Act on the rate the table above points to, not on the one that is easiest to move.
How We Approach This
Our performance work measures utilization and each project’s hours against its fee every week, so a falling realization shows while the project can still be steered. We start by going through your timesheets, fees and invoices, and every suggestion comes with the figures behind it.
Questions
What Is Realization in an Engineering Firm?
Realization compares what was billed with what the hours were worth at standard rates. For example, a project that used hours worth $50,000 and billed $42,000 has a realization of 84% (42,000 ÷ 50,000).
What Is the Difference Between Utilization and Realization?
Utilization measures time: how much went to billable work. Realization measures value: how much of that work turned into fees.
What Is Chargeability?
It is often another word for utilization. Some firms use it for all hours charged to a project number, billable or not, so the gap between the two shows project time nobody will pay for.
Can Realization Be Above 100%?
Yes, on a fixed-fee project that finishes in fewer hours than the fee allowed. The fee stays the same while the value of the hours used is lower.
Which Matters More?
Neither on its own. In our example, a firm with 80% utilization and 75% realization earns less from the same time than one with 70% utilization and 95% realization.
Updates
- : Rewritten at full length: realization on billing and on collection, where it leaks, how it changes the multiplier, reading the rates by project, client and kind of work, and a checklist.