Winning work
Qualifications-Based Selection: How Public Clients Choose Engineering Firms
Qualifications-based selection (QBS) is a way of choosing a design firm on its qualifications first and agreeing a fee only with the firm chosen. It is the rule for US federal architectural and engineering work, and one of several methods buyers in Canada use.
On this page
Terms Used
- Qualifications-based selection (QBS): choosing a design firm on its qualifications first, then agreeing a fee with the firm chosen.
- Statement of qualifications: a firm’s record, people and similar projects, submitted to be considered.
- Shortlist: the firms the client ranks as most qualified, in order of preference.
- Price-scored selection: a selection in which the fee is one weighted part of the score.
How It Works
Qualifications-based selection, usually called QBS, reverses the order of a price-first selection. Instead of comparing prices and then checking quality, the client ranks firms on their qualifications, chooses the best, and only then agrees a fee with that one firm. If they cannot agree, the client moves to the next firm on the list.
The reasoning is that design is a small share of a project’s lifetime cost, and the quality of the design decides much of the rest. Choosing a designer on price saves a little on the fee and risks a lot on the project.
QBS and Price-Scored Selection, Side by Side
| Question | Qualifications-based | Price scored |
|---|---|---|
| When the fee comes in | After the most qualified firm is chosen | With the proposal, often in a separate envelope |
| What wins | Record, team and approach | The weighted total of quality and price |
| How the fee is set | Negotiated with one firm, against the scope | Proposed by each firm, in competition |
| What the firm should invest in | Qualifications package, references, the interview | The technical proposal, and a price within reach of the lowest |
In US Federal Work: The Brooks Act
The Brooks Act sets the policy of the US federal government: to announce all requirements for architectural and engineering services publicly, and to negotiate contracts “on the basis of demonstrated competence and qualification for the type of professional services required and at fair and reasonable prices” (40 U.S.C. 1101). The steps, in sections 1103 and 1104:
- Agencies encourage firms to submit a statement of qualifications and performance data every year.
- For each project, the agency evaluates those statements and holds discussions with at least three firms.
- It selects, in order of preference, at least three firms it considers most highly qualified, on criteria it has published.
- It negotiates a fair and reasonable fee with the first. If that fails, it ends the negotiation formally and moves to the second, and so on.
That is the statute’s outline; agency regulations and each solicitation set the detail.
In setting the fee, the agency considers the “scope, complexity, professional nature, and estimated value of the services to be rendered” (40 U.S.C. 1104). That list is a guide for the firm too: the negotiation is about the work, not a discount.
In New York State
New York State Finance Law section 136-a sets the same policy for the state: contracts for architectural and engineering services are negotiated on the basis of demonstrated competence and qualification, at a fair and reasonable fee, starting with the most highly qualified firm; if that negotiation fails, the agency ends it and moves to the next (State Finance Law § 136-a). The section applies to services costing more than twenty-five thousand dollars.
In Quebec
Quebec’s rules for public contracts reserve three award rules for architecture and engineering services related to construction, and keep the lowest-price rules away from them: a quality-price weighting, which evaluates quality first and then considers the price; a design competition; and quality only, followed by negotiating the price with the firm with the best quality score (Gouvernement du Québec).
Each of these is a summary of published rules, not legal advice. The solicitation sets the procedure for each contract: read it, and check the current rules with counsel before relying on them.
In Ontario
Ontario has no single rule for every buyer. Each sets its own method and publishes it in the RFP, and many score quality and price together, with the weight given to price set buyer by buyer. The Ministry of Transportation’s engineering services procurement guide of June 2023 weighted a request for proposal at 65% for the technical proposal, 25% for the firm’s past performance rating and 10% for price (MTO, June 2023). Check the current guide before each submission, because the weights can change from one edition to the next.
What It Means for Your Proposals
Where selection is on qualifications, or where price carries a small weight, the proposal wins on the evidence that your firm and your team are the most qualified for this project. Three things follow:
- Your record is your price. Past performance ratings, references and similar projects carry the weight that a low fee carries elsewhere. Keep project sheets and résumés current; see statement of qualifications.
- Write to the criteria. The evaluation criteria are published. Build the response around them, in their order. See how to write an RFP response that scores.
- Know your costs before the negotiation. Under QBS, the fee is negotiated after selection. A firm that knows its overhead rate and the hours similar projects took can show why its fee is fair and reasonable.
Preparing for the Fee Negotiation
A QBS negotiation is a conversation about scope as much as fee. The firm that arrives with its hours by phase and role can show where the fee comes from, and when the client’s budget is lower, can offer a smaller scope rather than a lower rate.
- Confirm the scope in writing first. Deliverables, reviews, meetings, site visits and what is excluded.
- Bring the hours by phase and role, from similar projects the firm has done.
- Bring the rates and how they were set, from salary cost, overhead and profit. Our article on setting hourly rates shows the sum.
- Know your two figures. The break-even fee, which covers the hours and the overhead, and the target fee, which adds the profit you plan; see pricing engineering work.
- Trade scope, not rate. If the fee has to come down, agree what comes out of the work.
Where Price Is Scored
When price is scored, its weight tells you how to spend your effort. For example, assume the common formula in which the lowest fee earns all the price points and every other fee earns the lowest fee ÷ its own fee × the points: with 10 of 100 points for price, a fee 10% above the lowest scores 10 × 1 ÷ 1.1 ≈ 9.1, so the gap costs about one point. Buyers use different formulas, so read the one in the RFP.
| Example, round numbers, at 65 / 25 / 10 | Firm A | Firm B |
|---|---|---|
| Technical score out of 100, weighted to 65 | 80 → 52.0 | 90 → 58.5 |
| Past performance out of 100, weighted to 25 | 90 → 22.5 | 85 → 21.25 |
| Fee | Lowest | 15% above the lowest |
| Price points out of 10 | 10.0 | 10 ÷ 1.15 = 8.7 |
| Total | 84.5 | 88.45 |
In this example, Firm B wins with a fee 15% higher, because ten points of technical score are worth far more than the price gap. Read the weights before you decide how hard to sharpen the price, and before you decide to bid at all; see the go/no-go decision.
Common QBS Mistakes
- Treating the qualifications package as paperwork. On a QBS selection, it is the whole contest until the shortlist.
- Naming people who won’t do the work. Evaluators check, and past performance ratings remember.
- Arriving at the negotiation without hours. A fee without its working is easy to cut.
- Discounting the rate to close. A lower rate on the same scope comes straight out of the margin; a smaller scope doesn’t.
A Checklist for Qualifications-Based Work
- Keep the statement of qualifications, project sheets and résumés current all year.
- Read each RFP’s selection method and weights before deciding to bid.
- Build the response around the published criteria, in their order.
- Name the team that will do the work.
- Before the negotiation, confirm the scope and bring the hours by phase and role.
- Trade scope rather than rate if the fee must come down.
- Ask for a debrief, and record the scores by criterion.
How We Approach This
Our marketing work builds the proposal templates, project sheets and résumés that make a firm’s qualifications quick to show and easy to score, and our growth work reviews fee levels from your own timesheets and invoices, so the negotiation starts from your real costs.
Questions
What Is Qualifications-Based Selection?
A selection in which the client ranks firms on their qualifications, chooses the most qualified, and only then negotiates a fee with that firm. If they can’t agree, the client moves to the next firm on its list.
Is QBS Required for Engineering Services?
For US federal architectural and engineering contracts, yes, under the Brooks Act; some states, such as New York, have their own laws. In Ontario, each public buyer sets its own method in the RFP.
How Is the Fee Set Under QBS?
It is negotiated with the top-ranked firm. Under the Brooks Act the agency considers the scope, complexity, professional nature and estimated value of the services in setting a fair and reasonable fee.
How Much Does Price Matter When It Is Scored?
It depends on its weight and the formula. For example, at 10 of 100 points with the usual formula, a fee 10% above the lowest scores about 9.1 (10 ÷ 1.1), losing less than one point.
How Do I Prepare for a QBS Negotiation?
Confirm the scope in writing, bring the hours by phase and role from similar projects, know your break-even and target fees, and offer to reduce scope rather than rates if the fee must come down.
Sources
Updates
- : Rewritten at full length: QBS and price-scored selection side by side, how the Brooks Act sets the fee, preparing for the negotiation, a worked score at 65 / 25 / 10, common mistakes and a checklist; the Brooks Act and MTO guide re-read.