Winning work

Proposal Win Rate: How to Measure It, and What Is Typical

Sam&Sain Co. · Published · Updated · 6 minute read

A proposal win rate is the share of decided proposals a firm wins. Measured two ways, by count and by fee, and split by client and source, it shows whether the firm is choosing its pursuits well.

On this page

Terms Used

  • Win rate (hit rate): projects won as a share of proposals decided.
  • Decided: a proposal the client has awarded, to you or to someone else. Proposals still waiting, and cancelled requests, are not decided.
  • Shortlist rate: on two-stage selections, the share of qualification submissions that reach the shortlist.
  • Cost per win: the cost of all proposals in a period divided by the projects won.

Two Ways to Calculate It

Win rate by count = projects won ÷ proposals decided

Win rate by value = fees won ÷ fees proposed, on decided proposals

Count only proposals that have been decided. A proposal still waiting for an answer is neither a win nor a loss, and counting it lowers the rate for no reason. Leave out requests the client cancelled, too: nobody won them.

For example, over a year, a firm sends 50 proposals, and 40 have been decided. It won 14, so its win rate by count is 35%. The 40 decided proposals totalled $2,400,000 in fees, and the 14 it won totalled $1,100,000, so its win rate by value is 46%. The value rate is the higher one, so the proposals this firm won were larger, on average, than the ones it lost (about $78,600 each against $50,000), which is worth knowing when deciding which to pursue.

Two Stages: Shortlist, Then Win

Many public selections run in two stages: a statement of qualifications or expression of interest first, then proposals or interviews from a shortlist. One win rate across both stages hides where the firm is losing.

Example, round numbersCountRate
Qualification submissions20
Shortlisted (8 ÷ 20)840%
Won from the shortlist (3 ÷ 8)337.5%
Won overall (3 ÷ 20)315%

In this example, the overall figure looks poor, but the two stages say different things. A low shortlist rate points to the qualifications package, and our article on the statement of qualifications covers it. A low rate from the shortlist points to the proposal or the interview.

What Is Typical

The SMPS Foundation surveyed 303 US architecture, engineering and construction firms for its report Measuring for Success: A Look at Hit Rates & Other KPIs in the A/E/C Industries. It found average hit rates of 37% to 44% depending on the discipline, measured most commonly as projects won against proposals submitted. Engineering firms had the highest average, at 44.2% (reported by BD+C, January 2017).

Treat that as a rough reference. The survey is several years old, it covers US firms, and win rates vary a great deal with the mix of work. Your own rate, tracked the same way over time, is the useful number.

Split It

A single win rate hides the useful pattern. Split it by:

  • Client type: repeat clients, new private clients, public RFPs.
  • How the firm heard about it: discussed with the client before it was issued, or first seen on a bid site.
  • Project type and size.
  • Who led the proposal.

Split this way, compare the rate on repeat clients and pursuits you prepared for with the rate on public RFPs you answered cold. A large gap is a strong argument for a go/no-go decision before each one.

Count the Cost Too

Cost per win = salary cost of a group of proposals ÷ projects won from them

Record the hours each proposal took, and value them at salary cost. Leave overhead off: proposal time is already part of the overhead rate, so adding it again would count it twice. Take a group of pursuits, such as the proposals decided this year, add up what they cost, and divide by the wins from that same group. Costs and wins from the same pursuits keep one year’s spending from being divided by another year’s wins. It is the clearest way to see whether a lower win rate on a category of pursuit is worth it: a category with a low win rate and cheap proposals can cost less per win than one with a higher rate and expensive ones. The go/no-go article works through what a proposal really costs.

What a Rising or Falling Rate Means

  • Falling, with more proposals sent: the firm is chasing more, and choosing less. Deltek’s 2026 study found “more firms competing for a smaller share of available opportunities” despite “increasing the volume of project proposals” (Deltek, 26 May 2026).
  • Falling, on the same kind of work: rivals have improved, or the proposals have not kept up. Ask for debriefs.
  • Rising, with fewer proposals: better choices. Check that the fees won are holding up too.
  • Rising by count, falling by value: the firm may be winning the small ones and losing the large ones; check how large pursuits are staffed and priced.

Ask for a Debrief

A lost proposal is information the firm has already paid for. Ask the client for a debrief on every loss that mattered: how the proposal scored on each criterion, and what the winner did better. Public RFPs often say how to request one. Write the answers down beside the go/no-go record, and look for the pattern after a few: the same criterion scoring low is a fix the next proposal can make.

Keep It with the Other Numbers

Win rate is a monthly number, read with backlog: a falling win rate shows up in backlog a few months later.

Months of backlog = fees still to earn on signed work ÷ average monthly fees

For example, $1,500,000 of signed work still to deliver, at $250,000 of fees a month, is six months of backlog. If the win rate falls while backlog is long, there is time to act; if both fall together, the hiring and resource plan needs to know now. See engineering firm KPIs.

Common Win Rate Mistakes

  • Counting proposals still waiting. They lower the rate until they are decided.
  • Counting cancelled requests. Nobody won them, so they say nothing about the firm.
  • Mixing stages. Qualification submissions and proposals from a shortlist are different contests.
  • Reading only the count. The value rate shows whether the firm wins the work that matters most.
  • Never asking why. Without debriefs, a falling rate has no explanation.

A Checklist for Tracking Win Rate

  1. Log every proposal: client, type, size, source, lead, hours spent and fee proposed.
  2. Record each decision when it comes, and leave out cancelled requests.
  3. Calculate the rate by count and by value every month, on decided proposals.
  4. Track shortlist rate and win-from-shortlist separately on two-stage selections.
  5. Split the rate by client type, source, project type and lead each quarter.
  6. Work out the cost per win once a year.
  7. Ask for a debrief on every loss that mattered.
  8. Read the rate beside months of backlog.

How We Approach This

Why a firm wins some proposals and loses others is one of the questions our marketing work starts from: proposal templates, project sheets and résumés that make the case quickly, measured in shortlists, wins and fees.

Questions

What Is a Good Proposal Win Rate?

In the SMPS Foundation’s survey of 303 US firms (reported in 2017), engineering firms averaged a 44.2% hit rate. Compare your own rate over time and by type of client.

How Do You Calculate a Proposal Win Rate?

Divide the number of projects won by the number of proposals that have been decided. Leave out proposals still waiting for a decision, and requests the client cancelled.

What Is the Difference Between Hit Rate and Win Rate?

They usually mean the same thing: proposals won as a share of proposals decided.

Should Win Rate Be Measured by Count or by Value?

Both. For example, a firm that wins 14 of 40 decided proposals has a 35% rate by count; if those 14 total $1,100,000 of $2,400,000 proposed, its rate by value is 46% (1.1 ÷ 2.4).

What Is a Shortlist Rate?

On two-stage selections, the share of qualification submissions that reach the shortlist. Tracked apart from the win rate from the shortlist, it shows which stage loses the work.

Sources

Updates

  • : Rewritten at full length: two-stage selections with a worked example, cost per win, debriefs, months of backlog, common mistakes and a checklist; SMPS and Deltek re-read.

Discuss Your Project

Topic

We read every application. If we can help, the first 30-minute video call is free. Or contact us.